Shelters or Breeders: Which Is Better for Pet Adoption?

There are almost as many different kinds of cats and dogs as there are kinds of people—loud ones, quiet ones, energetic ones, lazy ones, hairy ones, clean-shaven ones, those that love kids, and those that want to be left alone. For someone looking for a pet, the big question often is, where exactly can I find what I’m looking for? 

Pet shelters are sometimes seen as the only humane and conscionable choice, but professional breeders offer peace of mind that shelters can’t guarantee. Both options have benefits and detriments, and it’s up to individual pet owners to decide which one best meets their needs. 

Be a Shelter Savior
The ASPCA estimates that about five to seven million animals enter shelters every year, and more than half are eventually euthanized because there’s no one to adopt them. The most important thing to remember is this—the pets relinquished at shelters aren’t bad cats and dogs. Many animals are given up because the previous owner wasn’t aware of the needs and challenges of a pet, or couldn’t handle the barking or separation anxiety that arose from the pet being left alone all day. Most often, the previous owner chose the animal because it was cute, and didn’t think about whether it was compatible with his or her lifestyle. Getting a pet from a shelter is a humane way to save the life of these perfectly lovable dogs and cats. 

The good news is that most shelter pets already have some housetraining and know basic commands. That makes training them immensely easier than training a pet from puppy- or kitten-hood. Shelters also routinely spay and neuter animals, bring them up-to-date on their shots and vaccinations, and do basic health tests. Some even include microchipping, in case the pet ever gets lost. The great thing about shelters is that they charge only a nominal fee for providing all these services, usually around $100. 

Shelters may do their best to be sure that dogs and cats are healthy and ready to be adopted, but unfortunately, there’s no way for them to tell what may have happened in an animal’s past. Although the majority of shelter animals are healthy and friendly, some have suffered diseases or injuries, mistreatment at the hands of their owners, or have serious intractable behavior problems that may be too much for the average pet owner to handle. For some pets, being in the shelter is traumatic, and they’re more likely to end up being clingy, skittish, territorial, or fearful.  

19 readers liked this story.
email
MORE WAYS TO SHARE Desc
I have always gotten my animals either from friends who couldn't take care of them anymore or from the shelter. Personally, I would always go with the shelter animals first. They are looking for people who will give them a nice home and lots of love. When I see the tv commercials on these poor sheltered animals or the ones that have been abused and rescued, it breaks my heart. I look at animals just like you would look at child. Beautiful and full of innocences.
10.27.2009
Isabel  Hartman
If you walk through a shelter just once, you'll never be able to get a pet from anyplace else again. The looks of all those dogs who want to go home with you - ack. It'll break your heart.
10.27.2009
Bijani Mizell
Animal shelters break my heart. I'd much rather rescue a dog that needs a good home than find a "perfect" breed of dog. I'm not super picky about my pets ... as long as it plays with me and licks my hand occassionally, I don't care what it looks like!
10.27.2009
Kay M. Daniels
I can understand why a person would want a pure-breed but my heart still goes out to those poor shelter animals. Must be a tough decision.
Before you see a breeder, stop by a shelter first - you'll change your mind.
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in!

most liked
Loader_buff
Sweeps_offers_article_300_top
What Do You Love Best About Your Cat? Share it and win $250!
What Do You Love Best About Your Cat? Share it and win $250!
Take our Cleaner Is Healthier Quiz and you could win $250.
Take our Cleaner Is Healthier Quiz and you could win $250.
Share a dream and win $250. We’ll draw a new winner every month!
Share a dream and win $250. We’ll draw a new winner every month!
VIEW ALL
Other topics you might appreciate
Play Career & Money Parenting