When You Should Treat the Man You Are Dating Like a Girlfriend

Are you an independent, smart, and single woman who is dating and looking for love? If so, you’ve likely been challenged with how to respond when a man does something that ticks you off. What are realistic expectations? What should you tolerate? I get asked this question in many forms.

It can be confusing. On the one hand, you have a strong desire to be liked and finally find “The One.” On the other hand, you are a confident woman who doesn’t want to put up with nonsense or be a pushover.

Here is how that conflict can look in real life: The part of you that wants to be liked accepts all sorts of silliness and disrespect, while the other part of you judges quickly and bails out at the first sign of trouble.

Consider the situation of my client, Christine. During her coaching session she complained that a man she connected with online has been calling her after 10pm. She thought that was rude. (So do I.) She wakes up at 5am., and it was affecting her sleep. She asked me if I thought she should say something to him. She was hesitant because she didn’t want to scare him away.

So I asked her: How would you deal with a girlfriend who kept calling at that hour? Her instant response was, “I’d talk to her and let her know that it wasn’t okay!”

There you go. It seems so clear if it’s a girlfriend, right? So why wouldn’t you respond the same way with a man you’re dating? This is a reasonable boundary. It’s intrusive behavior that affects your quality of life—not to mention it screams booty call.

When we date we tend to make our experiences all about him instead of ourselves. Does he like me? Did I say the right thing to him? What will he do next? Christine’s dilemma had very little to do with him; he was going to do what he was going to do. Rather, it was about her personal needs and whether she was going to take care of herself; even if it meant he left.

Setting personal boundaries is a constant. Having your “must-haves” honored should be expected of any relationship. There is no reason to make exceptions because he’s a guy and you’re afraid you’ll scare him off. If it’s something important enough to ask a girlfriend to do differently, then you probably want to address it with him. 

So . . . what can she do? If she goes with the side of her that wants to find a partner, she can simply accept his behavior. If she chooses the side that never wants to act like a desperate dater, she can dump him.

Or . . . she can realize there is another choice. Do what you would do with your girlfriend: tell him it’s not okay.

Here is the simple phrase I suggested Christine use to tell him what she would like: “Joe, I like you and I’m interested in getting to know you…but I work early so I don’t take calls after 9 p.m. If you want to get in touch, please call before that. I hope that works for you.” Direct, yet kind and non-demanding, right?

Whether we admit it or not, wanting to be liked is a huge part of the dating process. I think it’s important to clarify, though, that you want to be liked by the right men. When you politely tell Joe to please not call after 9, he can honor it or not. But you have honored yourself.

This really is pretty simple: take care of yourself with men the same way you do with your friends. A man doesn’t get a pass just because he’s hot and you really want to hook up. By the same token, there is no need to be demanding or critical; just ask and let him decide what he’s willing to do.

2 readers liked this story.
From Around the Web:
06.21.2011
Bobbi Palmer
Thanks to you both for reading and for your comments! It's such an old story that women want men to read their minds. I definitely did for a loooong time before I learned otherwise. I find that once I help my coaching clients with some specific words to use, their fear subsides and they are far more comfortable asking for what they want. 9 times out of 10 the men are grateful (like John says) and, like you said MJ, they respect it. For the one guy that doesn't, they move on. And that's a not a bad thing, right?
06.21.2011
MJ
Yep ladies, I agree with John. It is better to tell them what our bounderies are because they don't read our minds. Don't forget to set your bounderies because you are desperate to be liked. Guys respect women who have respect for themselves.
06.20.2011
John
It's that simple, Bobbi: Tell me the boundaries. If I am calling a lady at a bad time, and she never tells me as much, how am I supposed to know? As a man, I want to impress a lady. So if I am givien a boundary, any boundary, I will want to honor it as a way to impress her and show respect. It's frustrating to violate a boundary that I never knew existed, only because I was never told. The lady gets upset, I can't figure out why, then I am confused, so I figure "I'll never do THAT again" - but I am not entirely sure what THAT was. Then I am labeled a jerk for not being able to figure it out for myself. Can you say "communicate"? Oh, and ladies, you are NEVER obligated to answer your phone (or your front door, for that matter!) Don't forget who's life you are living. If you tell a guy not to call after a certain hour, but he still does, let the machine pick it up. For that matter, unplug the phone before you go to bed and have a good night's sleep!
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in!

Article_sweeps
Most Liked Stories
Loader_buff
Sweeps_offers_article_300_top
Win a $10,000 escape to Jamaica! Enter as often as you wish.
Win a $10,000 escape to Jamaica! Enter as often as you wish.
VIEW ALL