A Man’s Take on Advice in Women’s Magazines

“Why won’t he commit?”

“Get your man to say ‘I do!’”

“Why don’t guys call when they say they will?”

Peruse any magazine rack and various Web sites and you’ll see headlines such as these splattered all over. Inside you’ll read article upon article about how women can decode, seduce, corral, turn on, and coerce men.

One is left to believe that men don’t want to be married or in any sort of committed relationship, men don’t want to treat women well, men don’t want families, men don’t want to settle down, and worst of all, men don’t even have the desire or the ability to communicate any of this about themselves. Good thing we smell so good.

As a man, I’m starting to feel gosh … a little … frustrated … angry … defensive.

I don’t see much out there to counter these sorts of articles, perhaps because men’s magazines are outnumbered by women’s magazines by about fifty to one (my unofficial estimate).

So please allow me to defend my gender so I can put some different lines in your head.

See, I happen to know men who are actually nice, intelligent, and kind—men who want families, treat women well, and are ready to settle down. I’ll leave their information for you at the bottom of the page. (Now, you’ll read on!) 

Ah, ha. But my last parenthetical statement is just as false of an assumption about women as all the negative media rhetoric is about men. 

I happen to know women who don’t want to be married and/or in a serious relationship. I know women who aren’t the articulate, clear communicators they’re supposed to be. I know women who aren’t that into kids and don’t want a family. 

So pardon my frustration, and other men’s, when we read articles portraying us as the incapable, the insincere, and the incompetent gender.

44 readers liked this story.
share
POST
Comments
05.15.2009
Lauren Young
Thank you for this article. My brother thanks you, and he is the one I always go to if I have "guy questions." I agree with your points, and enjoyed reading it, also. Thank you, again.
05.15.2009
Michal Merhej
I loved the article. I'm so glad to say that i once WAS that kind of girl.. but not any more. I believe it is that bitter feeling we get after many disappointments, that gets us there!
05.14.2009
Rowdygirl
This is pretty good. I have to agree with most of what you've said, but I have yet to meet those really good guys you mentioned.. :) I think that women's magazines all have the same underlying message: women are inadequate, in every area, and need to be fixed. There would be no reasons for the magazines to exist otherwise.. what would they be selling? Happiness and self acceptance ?HA ! Teaching us to "fix" all the guys out there is just another way to say we're not good enough and that's why men don't want us.
02.02.2009
Lizzie
Excellent article. Straight to the point.
01.31.2009
Sindy
wat if a guy stop callin u coz they got into an argument? does it mean he simply doesnt care or wat?? o_O?
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in—maybe get a little famous. And don't worry—you can save a draft!

most liked
Loader_buff
Other topics you might appreciate
Play Parenting