Why Kids? The Great Debate

Last week, I wrote a post about my conversation with a friend who doesn’t want kids. I talked about how when she told me this it was like she was speaking a foreign language. One that I barely understood. No kids? Never? Never ever? No kids. Ever, she confirmed. Okay. I was a tad anxious about publishing the post because I am well aware that this kids/no kids topic is a thicket of controversy. Thankfully, my anxiety didn’t paralyze me (this time). I published. And waited (like we bloggers do) for the comments to roll in (or not roll in. Sob.)  And roll in, they did. Amazing comments. Diverse voices. Strong opinions.

I was thrilled at the participation, but more than that I was thrilled at the continuum of reactions. I was heartened by the gentleness, the unanticipated diplomacy, the conspicuous open-mindedness. I was pleasantly surprised at the number of people who chimed in who: (a) are not parents; and (b) do not plan to be. Don’t get me wrong. I love parents. I am a parent. This is my world. But. These comments from members of the human species who do not have wee ones (and do not crave wee ones) underscored the fact that this blog, however young and sprightly and scattered, appeals to an audience broader than moms. Yay. This blog is not just reaching clones of Aidan! This is exactly what I want. Depth. Diversity. Grays.

But something struck me about the content of these comments. Something upset me. That something? The vast majority of those who declared that they do not want kids also stated that they are constantly asked to justify this life choice to others. I can’t imagine this. Frankly, I am quite the mainstream cliché. I went to college, then law school, then started my career, then married, then popped out a couple of (freakishly cute) kids. No one has asked me to justify my path. Ever. (Wait, not entirely true. A few people asked me to justify the whole novel writing dream. You know who you are.)

2 readers liked this story.
share
POST
I have just completed another (unsuccessful) round of IVF. It failed 2 days ago, so I find myself crying uncontrollably at different points during the day. I cry for my loss (the embryo was so cute); I cry for the child that embryo could have become; I cry because I know I would be a good mother; because I have so much to teach a small person; and yes, because I want to be visited later in life; I want to feel rejuvenated when my children have children; I want to see a likeness of myself and my husband in another; I want to see the fusion of our love. It's a difficult world, and I believe that having children should have some thought put into it. The sad truth is that so very often that does not happen - how often do I see women in the street screaming at their kids as if it's the child's fault that they can no longer cope with the additional responsibility and financial burden a child brings? No space left, I'll have to continue this in an article..
12.04.2009
DCPatient
Being in the midst of a fertility journey I finally did stop and ask this question. It did stump me for a bit, but I finally realized that I be honored to have the opportunity to love someone unconditionally and nurture someone with total appreciation and acceptance from the moment I was aware of their existence. What a great gift to give to another person. What would we all be capable of if we each had that.
11.24.2009
1seoshop
I love children.They complete the family.In my opinion a couple without kids will be very sad. [url=http://seoconsultinglv.com]LAS VEGAS SEO[/url
11.24.2009
Irina
I always thought the question: why not have kids, is the wrong one to ask. The logical question is why do have them? well... for me the answer for planning to have my own kids is that I think they're incredibly cute. Plus... with all my reasons for having it better without, I can't escape the urge to have kids given by the instinct placed within me. It's also something quite selfish - I want to see my genes reproduced. I want to have this small person that I can call mine without being mistaken(well... at least for the first couple of years), that adores me and whom I adore unconditionally. At the same time I realize it is a self destructive thing. But... most of us, will listen to their instincts rather than to their reason. I'm one of these people...
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in—maybe get a little famous. And don't worry—you can save a draft!

most liked
Loader_buff
Other topics you might appreciate
Play Home & Food Neighborhood & World