Does Birth Order Shape Our Personalities?

Scientists the world over have spent countless words and oceans of ink debating the issue of nature versus nurture. But how your child develops might have as much to do with the order in which they were born, as it does with their genes or environment.

Alfred Adler, a contemporary of Freud and Jung, first put forth the idea, claiming that when a child is born deeply impacts their personality. According to Adler …

Eldest children are socially dominant, highly intellectual, and extremely conscientious. Unfortunately, they’re also less open to new ideas, and prone to perfectionism and people pleasing—the result of losing both parents’ undivided attention at an early age, and working throughout their lives to get it back.

Middle children, sandwiched between older and younger siblings, often develop a competitive nature, making them natural entrepreneurs later in life. They tend to be the most diplomatic and flexible members of the family and often, eager for parental praise, develop musical or academic gifts.

Youngest children, according to birth order theory, tend to be dependent and selfish—as they’re used to others providing for them. But despite the negatives, they’re also quite often the life of the party—fun, confident, and comfortable entertaining others.

And only children? Like last borns, they are regularly spoiled, according to Adler, and have a hard time when they don’t get their own way. School can be a particularly difficult transition, as they’re used to being the center of the familial universe. But all that parental focus pays off. Only children are often mature for

15 readers liked this story.
share
POST
07.14.2009
Just Ask Baby
A child’s personality is determined both by heredity and by experience. Renowned child psychologist David Elkind explores this topic in his blog post on Birth Order Effects: http://www.justaskbaby.com/blogs/professor‐elkind/birth‐order‐effects
07.08.2009
Cheekyredhead
This article sort of dwelled on the negatives...but there are postives in each birth order as well. As the oldest I have always been a natural organizer--so I prefer to think of that as a positive trait. My sister the middle child was outgoing, daring, and very insightful. I always wished I had her head for numbers. That is a positive. Alas the last two of my siblings were twins, a girl and a boy. I do not think they were spoiled at all. My brother was given a bit more attention as the only boy, but he was far from spoiled and his twin received as much because they were twins. As the youngest they are both very creative people--people persons--so I see that as positives too. I think birth order/maturity affects how we "percieve" each other and our situations. As the oldest I rarely got away with misbehaving...my younger siblings were given more room. Maybe my parents relaxed finally. We all remember things differently--even events in our shared past.
07.05.2009
Michelle
This was done by Alfred Adler as one of his most known works of Psychology. This is not something new, it's been around since the late 1950's. You have to look at when this was developed... it was more likely for you to grow up in a house with two parents who didn't have other children from previous marriages. You also were more likely to have stay at home mom and a working dad, now both parents are working and the style of parenting has considerably loosened up. Just look around at the things kids do today and how many times you've thought to yourself "Man! My mom would kill me if I ever did anything like that" or "That would never fly in my house". It is all relevant to time the study was done in the 50's not so much now.
07.05.2009
AJ ROD
Madona. I agree with you and even tho i havent read all the other posts. How can they come up with money to fund studies like this? Cigarette smokers are still smoking the same brand even with the economy. How can they fund irrelavent topics?
07.04.2009
madonna
I don't think this is very accurate. I am the oldest, of my mom kids, but have an older brother from my dad, but was not raised with them. I am very smart, i play the piano, I am shy, a perfectionist, and quite honestly could give a rats you-know-what about pleasing other people. So, where do I fall? Am I the oldest because i am my moms oldest, or the 2nd born because my dad has one older than me, that i don't know? It amazes me that a study like this was even paid for, are there not better places that that money could have gone to??????
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in—maybe get a little famous. And don't worry—you can save a draft!

most liked
Loader_buff
Other topics you might appreciate
Play Home & Food Neighborhood & World