Nine Cold, Hard Weight-Loss Truths


2. A half-hour walk doesn’t equal a brownie.
I remember going out to eat with some friends after a bike ride. Someone commented on how we deserved dessert because we had just spent the day exercising; in fact, we had taken a leisurely twenty-minute ride through the park. This probably burned the calories in a slice of our French bread, but definitely not those in the caramel fudge brownie dessert. Bummer.

And while it’s easy to underestimate how many calories something has, it’s also easy to overestimate how many calories we burn while exercising. Double bummer.

Even if you exercise a fair amount, it’s not carte blanche to eat whatever you want. (Unless you exercise a ton, have the metabolism of a sixteen-year-old boy, and really can eat whatever you want). A report investigating the commonly-held beliefs about exercising, published in the Journal of the American Dietetic Association, concludes that although exercise does burn calories during and after exercise, for overweight persons, “excessive caloric expenditure has limited implications for substantially reducing body weight independent of nutritional modifications.” In other words, to lose weight, you have to cut calories and increase exercise.

3. You have time to exercise.
If you have time to check email, watch a sitcom or two, surf the internet, have drinks/coffee/dinner with friends, go clothes shopping, and on and on, then you have time to exercise. Yes, sometimes you have to sacrifice sleep, TV, or leisure time to fit it in. Yes, sometimes you have to prioritize your exercise time over other things. But your health and the feeling you get after having worked out is well worth it.

4. Eating more of something won’t help you lose weight.
The food industry is keen to latch onto weight loss research and spin it for their sales purposes. A prime example is the widespread claim that eating more dairy products will help you lose weight. However, a recent review of forty-nine clinical trials from 1966 to 2007 showed that “neither dairy nor calcium supplements helped people lose weight.”

This idea—that eating more of a certain type of product will help you lose weight—is constantly regurgitated on supermarket shelves (think low-fat cake, low-carb crackers, high in whole grain cookies, and trans fat-free chips), but is in direct opposition to the basic idea behind weight loss—that we have to eat less, not more.

114 readers liked this story.
share
POST
02.16.2010
Kelly Rowland
The last point you made is really what 'diet's should be: a commitment to a lifestyle change instead of trying to lose weight as quickly as possible. Some of those weight loss truths can be difficult to swallow if we're not in the right mindset to lose weight and keep it off for good without changing how we got to be overweight in the first place. Thanks for the reminder that it does take hard work but more importantly, a commitment to a lifestyle change.
04.24.2009
Clara
Great article! I especially liked the last point. So many of my friends ascribe to these fad diets and wonder why they gain weight again, then tell me I must have a really high metabolism. I don't have an especially high metabolism, I've just learned to create a lifestyle I can handle that allows me to stay at my idea weight. One thing people don't realise, though, is to lose weight and keep it off, you need to eat. Eating 1200 calories is only going to screw up your metabolism and make it harder to keep the weight off. Eat at least 1500 calories (NET calories, not total) and exercise at least three days a week to the point where your heart rate is consistantly up to 20-30 min and your breaking a sweat. It's just one step to a better life.
02.27.2009
Roni
TOTALLY awesome article! However I'd like to comment on point 1. I agree exercise is important but tackling the diet/food front may be more important. Being a yo-you dieter who has finally lost 65+ pounds and kept it off for over 3 year now I had to tackle my issues with diet and food. Once I did that I was able to lose weight at my current activity level. Telling someone who is struggling with weight they need to workout for an hour or more may deter them from actually attempting to lose weight. As they say.. baby steps. :) Exercise is important but it is possible to lose through diet alone. Maintaining that loss however, will be more difficult without the commitment to a more active lifestyle. I have to add I am now an avid runner and lift weight 2-3 times a week. ;~)
01.07.2009
Shag The Daddyo
I've been overweight twice and it makes me depressed. I got down to no job so no cash and not much for food. I found that having less activity meant I should eat less. Being down and out so I'm actually hungry is very spiritual experience for me. It seems to cleanse my body , mind and spirit. I recommend it for all excessively plump people. One meal daily is enough food to keep an inactive body going strong. I can testify to that.
01.06.2009
Dave
So true, kick off the "new year's resolution" and make a permanent change. Most people don't get past February with the diet and fitness changes. One hour of hard core work with your body will incur changes. You can walk all the stairs, shovel all the snow you want but unless you are doing this for at least twenty minutes you will not begin to burn the fat stores in your body. Greater than twenty minutes (ie one hour) will challenge you but with time it will show results. Start slow (twenty minutes for the firtst month), then add ten minutes a month until you get to sixty minutes of taking moderate to severe effort exercise. As always check with your Doctor first before starting any exercise program. Do it on the daily or at a minimum five days a week. It takes time to gain weight so to lose it takes time as well. And remember if you grind it out you will be happy with the results.
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in—maybe get a little famous. And don't worry—you can save a draft!

most liked
Loader_buff
Other topics you might appreciate
Career & Money Neighborhood & World Parenting