The Permagrin: Being Forced to Smile

Smiling is great ... I’m all for it. It has a lot of great benefits and makes you feel all warm and fuzzy. But let’s face it: there are times when you just don’t want to smile. It doesn’t matter what the reason is. It is human. It is natural. And there is no reason for you to feel bullied into smiling if, at that very moment, you just don’t feel like it.

This morning I was perfectly content in my own world, deep in thought about all the things I had to get done today, and BAM, I hear someone say, “Brett … SMILE.” My co-worker obviously assumed that my not smiling implied that I was unhappy. As a result, he jolted me out of deep thought and tried to command me to smile. What is that? Where is it written that if you don’t smile there must be something wrong with you? Aren’t we past the “Beaver Cleaver” days of society? The “I must smile and look perfect all the time” era? People ... no one should be expected to smile twenty-four hours a day! 

I remember a similar time when I was in college. My father was very sick, and one evening I was on the pay phone with my mom getting an update on his condition. At some point during the conversation, my classmate who I barely knew, passed by and told me to “SMILE.” It actually made me feel worse. I felt it was completely insensitive. I was obviously having a serious and private conversation (as private as one could possibly have at a public pay phone), listening intently to the details about my dad, and this stranger, who had no idea who I was talking to or what I was talking about, imposed his permagrin expectations on me. Maybe I should have been “touched” by this person’s supposed concern about my state of mind, but he didn’t even know me, he didn’t even understand the situation, and he didn’t know what was going on inside of me. He just had it in his mind that I should be smiling.

There are times that being reminded to smile can be a good thing. It can help us gain perspective. But it shouldn’t be demanded of us. If someone needs some deep thought time, is having a bad day, or just doesn’t feel “smiley,” they should have the right to not smile. Moreover, making an individual feel self-conscious about how they look when they are unhappy, are having a bad day, or are receiving not-so-great news, isn’t helpful. An individual has every right to not smile ... whatever the reason. 

Has anyone told you to smile? How did it make you feel?

5 readers liked this story.
From Around the Web:
03.15.2009
sara kimmerle
Yay! I loved your piece. I actually smile quite a lot, I feel. But when I'm concentrating, or stressed, I obviously look in need of a reminder to smile. Since my name is Sara, it was not uncommon in the 80s to have people come up to me and actually sing "Sara Smile". Nothing could make me feel more homicidal. To this day I hate that song. What makes people feel they have the right to tell someone to smile? Obviously, if you felt like smiling you WOULD be smiling! Now I just look at them brightly and say, "Why?". They always seem at a loss for an answer.
03.15.2009
rozebud
Yes! Finally someon else knows the feeling! I am almost 30 and I grew up in a so called "Leave it to Beaver" world, but it was just that. 'Leave it to Beaver' on the outside and completely disfunctional in reality. I can't say I was really ever a happy child and I now can see a lot of the reason why was because of the fake 'persona' we were forced to live in. I had 3 brothers and sisters and my father was extremely strict on making us come off to the world as a perfect family. It was an unbelievable amount of pressure for any child to sustain. Before I hit my pre-teens I became very depressed and over the years it became treatment-resistent depression. It's something I began to accept was normal - feeling sad all the time. It was something I felt I shouldn't show and to cover it with a 'fake' smile. It's taken years to reverse that kind of thinking and I do feel I'm now beginning to realize that when I smile it should be because I feel like it not because people want me to.
03.03.2009
Kharmaisis
I absolutely HATE it when people tell me to smile, it actually gives me a violent feeling (thankfully not a violent reaction) but I just want to scream. If i am intensly working, someone telling me to smile breaks my focus and for someone with ADHD, that is REALLY annoying. If i am just 'taking it all in' and someone tells me to smile, i feel like they have invaded my calm. Smiling for me I guess is a personal thing and I want to reserve the right to smile when I deem it appropriate. Besides, nothing in life is more fake than a fake smile.
03.03.2009
Robyn
Those people make me CRAZY! So, I usually come back with some dry sarcasm - "Why? Did I just win the lottery?" "No?" "Oh, then shut up" Then I smile.
Well put! I am all about being happy and peppy but people are allowed to have a bad day every now and then without having to worry about putting on an act. I think if someone is a little down that last think they want to hear is, “SMILE!” as if doing so will solve all his or her problems. Great topic.
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in!

Article_sweeps
Most Liked Stories
Loader_buff
Sweeps_offers_article_300_top
Win a $10,000 escape to Jamaica! Enter as often as you wish.
Win a $10,000 escape to Jamaica! Enter as often as you wish.
VIEW ALL