Substance-Seeker: Stepford Stories

My whole life, I’ve been accused of being too serious. I confess this is umm, probably, mostly ... okay, okay … it’s totally true. My kids have lightened me up considerably. However, I am still very serious about lots of things. I’m fiercely loyal, have an obsession with social justice, and am compulsive about seeking out whether or not the people I know or come into contact with have any substance.

I’ve been accused of being aloof and that’s probably fair. I like to observe people before committing to as much as a conversation. I’m not a grocery-line talker or a ladies fitting-room chit chatter. I can be charming, but I’m really not good at frivolity. And Stepford is nothing if not frivolous.

Okay, so it’s through this lens of substance-seeking that I view the world. It has shaped my love-hate relationship with Stepford and created the environment where I can count on one hand the number of people whom I actually call my friends. There are lots more people who I’m friendly with, but when I says friends, I mean someone I would actually wake up in the middle of the night if I needed something and who I wouldn’t curse if they called and woke me up. It is also the lens through which I view Sarah Palin. Hmmm … it has been a less than flattering lens to use on her.

My reaction to her surprised even me. It was immediate, harsh, and unyielding. I was, for lack of a more eloquent word, revolted. Now, my rational brain told me that this was ridiculous, that I shouldn’t feel any worse about her than I do, say Dick Cheney … or George Bush. My rational brain also told me that my overreaction to Palin should be telling me something about myself. Hmmm … now this is getting interesting. I love introspection. So for the last seven weeks while I’ve been ranting, raving, and throwing what we call in Texas a “hissy fit” about Palin, my brain has been working over time trying to put my finger on exactly what it is about Palin, besides the obvious, that has nearly made me lose my mind.

As with most things in my life that I over analyze, the answer felt tantalizingly close, on the tip of my tongue, my fingers brushing against it as I reached out to grab it, a dream that faded from my memory quickly upon awakening, a familiar face I just couldn’t place. Until … Saturday night. I hadn’t planned on watching Palin on Saturday Night Live. However, my husband really wanted to see it, so I watched. The opening segment elicited nothing more than an eye-roll from me as Alec Baldwin told Palin, “You’re so much hotter in person.” Seriously, can we pleeeease stop talking about how “hot” the potential Vice-President is? Can we not show a little respect at least for the office? At this point, my husband fell asleep and I went back to my book.

Then the Weekend Update began and I once again turned my attention to the television. Palin feigned changing her mind about the rap she had planned to do and Amy Poeler agreed to step in. Poeler then began her rap about Alaska. And then it happened … the camera cutting to Palin as Poeler rapped … Palin dancing in her seat, raising the roof, giving an “Ayers” to Poeler’s “Obama” … and the allusiveness of my outrage revealed itself as nothing more than this—familiarity. Oh yes, no doubt, Palin’s deficits in education and experience, her out of touch policy stances, her dialect, all that still bothers me … would be enough on its own to make me speak out against her. But what was making me lose my ever loving mind was the surface-level similarities between us.

Her age, her brunette hair, her goateed husband, her children, her clothes … her SUV … all of it was just too much like me. EXCEPT … I can’t find any substance. I keep looking and I don’t see it. And for me, there would be nothing worse than looking in the mirror and seeing no substance beyond the hair and makeup … looking in the mirror and seeing nothing more than an average everyday Stepford Wife. So, has my objective opinion of Palin changed? No, not a bit. But now that I’ve located the source of my revulsion, I can relax, content in the knowledge that just because I think Palin is all hat and no cattle, I am under no obligation to be the same.

11 readers liked this story.
From Around the Web:
11.15.2008
Jamie
Hahahhaa. "...All hat and no cattle." You are from Texas. =) Great article.
10.30.2008
Daniel
Caitlyn, doubtless you have probably visited more than one forum during this historic run for the Presidency & weighed in with your thoughts. Certainly, you have found, as I & many others have, that a disproportionately large number of McCain/Palin advocates, especially the Palinites (considering her selection was calculated to excite the GOP base), have posted the most ignorant, occasionally racist, uninformed, half-lies, & bizarre comments in support of the GOP ticket, while denigrating Obama as just this side of an Islamic 'Shaitan' (Arabic for Satan). Most of their ignorance is fueled by Christian wing nut beliefs, blustery right wing talk radio, & most tragically, by the McCain/Palin campaign, especially in the person of Sarah Palin. Surely, you don't expect common sense or cogent, well-thought out arguments from people immersed in the radical Islamic-like fanaticism also engendered in the fundamentalist Christian sects? There is little difference between the two. Both are scary!
10.29.2008
Caitlyn Merwin
Felix: 1) Please stop referring to Palin as a "girl", she is over 18 and in line (heaven help us) to possibly become the Vice President, last time I checked this qualified her as a woman and as one of her few supporters in this forum I would expect you to be the last one to demean her in this way. 2) In reference to your justification for partial birth abortions being illegal "Contraception is cheap". Yes it is cheap, however with record numbers of teenagers pregnant (including Palin's own daughter) for some reason contraception being cheap does not seem to be enough... could it POSSIBLY have anything to do with Abstinence Only Sex Education?
10.27.2008
Daniel
As for Obama's tax policies, why is it wrong to take a larger chunk of taxes from people who make more money? And McCain's garbage about it being a "responsibility" instead of a right for humans in the country to have decent health care...are you kidding me? We are not even in the top 20 industrialized countries in terms of infant mortality rates. That is outrageous! Average, everyday people are having troubles keeping their homes, buying food and clothing for their families, much less health care. Meanwhile, Dubya has given $700 Billion to bail out Wall Street, and taken over Fannie Mae & it's twin (in receivership), on the financial tax backs of the middle class. And the CEO of both those institutions will make in excess of $14 Million in this year of near-economic collapse. And that is par for Big Business. Where in hell are they tightening their belts? Show me that, and then you can deign to talk to me about Obama's tax policies, and plan to get us back on our feet. Get real, dude!
10.27.2008
Daniel
There is no getting around the fact that Palin is way out of her policy depth as a veep candidate. Whenever she has gone off-script, and to the McCain campaign's horror, the words and what paltry few ideas she tries to talk about are either poorly expressed, impossible to understand, and frankly, it is apparently a major challenge for the woman to speak in cogent, clear and well-constructed sentences. Now I know all you Palinites love the fact that she's just like you...soccer mom, religious wing-nut, Joe the Plumber, etc...and all that mediocre garbage. That's EXACTLY what we don't need, is some average, everyday schmuck one heartbeat away from the most powerful office in the world. Hell, fricking NO! I don't want some Yay-hoo from Alaska who can't string together an intelligible sentence, or who thinks that just because she can see Russia from her back door, she knows what the Russians are all about, become Veep. I don't know what planet some of you Palinites inhabit. Not earth....
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in!

Article_sweeps
Most Liked Stories
Loader_buff
Sweeps_offers_article_300_top
Win a $10,000 escape to Jamaica! Enter as often as you wish.
Win a $10,000 escape to Jamaica! Enter as often as you wish.
VIEW ALL