Can Animal Activism Go Too Far?

Weighing the Impact
At some level, PETA’s tactics have worked. With more than 2 million members across the globe, PETA is the largest animal advocacy group and comparable in size to the human rights organization, Amnesty International. Yet as effective as their guerilla tactics are at grabbing the passerby’s attention, they also make PETA seem ridiculous at times.

Most disturbing, though, is that the same (if not more brazen) use of women as sex objects to sell alcohol and fast cars is used by PETA to promote animal rights. PETA’s President Newkirk has argued that the women who volunteer for PETA campaigns are not being exploited, but have decided to make statements with their bodies. She also points out that the average person isn’t going to decide to read about animal cruelty, but if they click on a Web link to see a nearly naked Alicia Silverstone, they just might take the time to find out why she is a vegetarian. The key word, though, is might. Getting a peek of Alicia’s hot body is unlikely to inspire a desire to learn about slaughterhouses. Meanwhile, PETA is promoting the idea that women, even impassioned, smart activists, must rely on their bodies to be heard. That seems to be a gigantic step back for women’s rights, even if it is for the puppies’ sake.

6 readers liked this story.
From Around the Web:
Way to go Joanne Chang! Very well said. I'm tired of hearing from others what they think I ought to do with my body or how I ought to feel about it. Sarah you say naked as if that's a bad thing....since when is nudity the same as porn? I feel that you are doing the same thing Peta is doing by beefing up propaganda when you say that. Peta is pushing some of us hardcore vegans away with their tactics no doubt, but nude is nature and as a beautiful woman if I choose to share that with the world that can only be seen as a positive thing. Although I don't agree with Peta, for instance they would like to ban all Pit Bulls which is like banning all Muslims from airports, but the insane over the top antics of the animal farming industry and the lame a$$ complacency of Americans to let it continue it is almost a big joke that it continues which requires a paradigm shift in consciousness for us before we see that we are all acting like big buffoons to continue to allow such torture.
I agree with PETA and the intense manner they use to get their point across. This country is bent on destroying anything or anyone that is unable to defend themselves/itselves. As that old adage goes, the fit of the fittest survives. I believe we all our on earth to do good work and for those that have no voice, need folks like PETA, Children Agencies, and other protective agencies to give cause like these a voice. Who cares if a woman shows her naked body? Get over it, already, this is the 21st Century! Why should people kill animals to wear as status symbols? This country is over the top with excess, materialism, and greed! I think it is great that PETA is a strong group! Rock on, PETA!
05.25.2009
EdenSprings
Can activism go too far? Well, let's rate which of these PETA-ideas are over the top: 1. Publish a comic book featuring a crazed housewife stabbing a blood-soaked rabbit on the cover with the title of "Your Mommy Kills Animals!" and distribute it to school kids. 2. Claim you are Pro Animal, but in 2008 report that of the 2,216 animals you took into your only shelter in Virginia, you euthanized (er...killed) 2,209 of them. 3. In April, Ingrid Newkirk handed out clubs to demonstrators to kill harp seals in Canada in order to save the cod (er...sea kittens). 4. Ingrid has publicly stated that she would rather save the life of a single lab rat than find a cure for cancer. 5. All of the above Find out what PETA's secret agendas are and how they're duping you by visiting this site: http://www.activistcash.com/organization_overview.cfm/o...
05.22.2009
Jean Richardson
You said ." People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals doesn’t threaten researchers’ lives or condone bombing laboratories like more militant animal rights groups" This is not true. PETA supports and defends the violent terroist groups. They have never denied this or denounced the violence. PETA is not a group for animal lovers. It is a group for human haters.
05.22.2009
Joanne Chang
Attacking women who willingly take off their clothes for a cause is a mesogenistic act. The reason I say that is because naked men (yes, men are used in stunts too. But they just get to have fun.) never have to justify why they are "exploiting" thier bodies. It's as if society readily accepts that men just owns thier bodies and they are free to do whatever they want with it. But when women do it, we are suddenly "objectifying" themselves and being 'exploited" by those who look at us. I agree with you that there's a deep prejudice in how society treats women and it has nothing to do with whether or not we use our bodies for a cause. It's extremely unfair that men get to go home after doing a naked stunt while women remain behind to be stoned by questions about why they have made decisions about their bodies without discussing it with the rest of the society first.
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in!

Article_sweeps
Most Liked Stories
Loader_buff
Sweeps_offers_article_300_top
Win a $10,000 escape to Jamaica! Enter as often as you wish.
Win a $10,000 escape to Jamaica! Enter as often as you wish.
VIEW ALL