Curly vs. Straight: Which Do Men Prefer?

First impressions count. Many closet curlies are married to a flat iron because they think men prefer the smooth, straight look over curls or kinks. And when you can maneuver your mane in either direction, you have the option of changing your visual impression when meeting someone new.

But should you? And would it really make a difference?

To find out, I embarked on an unscientific social experiment. Newly single in New York City, I joined a popular online dating service and posted two profiles. They were identical in every way—except one. The first profile included a picture of my hair flat-ironed straight. For the other, my hair was naturally curly. After one month showcasing the straight profile and the next month curly, more than twice as many men responded to the straight look.

More Details:

  • The straight profile was viewed 1,606 times for the month, while the curly one received 1,063 views during the month it was posted
  • The flat-ironed look 181 emails, compared with 60 for the curly profile
  • On the flirtatious side, the stick-straight profile received 120 winks, while curly locks caught winks from 60 men
  • In about 10 percent of the dates, hair made a difference, while confidence was the driving factor in the remainder of the connections


But this experiment is far from over. There’s a twist. On my dates, the plan was to find out what they really think when I show up as the opposite of what they expect. If they reach out to my straight profile, I would meet them as a curly, and vice versa. Would my hairstyle really affect their attraction? It was an adventure that was full of surprises. My one rule: I vowed to only date men I was truly interested in. This is the real deal, real dates, real men. Here’s a snapshot—you be the judge.

Bachelor #1: Financial-Services Executive
This is my first date. I’m nervous on the entire cab ride to the restaurant, wondering if my date will even recognize me. He expects stick-straight locks. I’m curly. I quickly phone a friend for reinforcement. I’m connected to voicemail, hang up, then glance at the cabbie. He seems nice enough. I bend his ear.

193 readers liked this story.
share
POST
Comments
Try Brazilian Blowout to smooth your hair out, and have your curls back in a few months. You can even wear it wavy in between! www.jordanalorraine.com
06.30.2009
Mike Kroboth
You have gorgeous curly hair! Don't ever change it!!!!!!
06.29.2009
I like both
Looking again, in a fewer words; the curly picture says "Nice girl", the straight says "Niiiiiiiiice!"
06.29.2009
I like both
I have a suggestion as a perhaps overly-analytical male. The next time you do an experiment, try using one hair style, but take one picture with a tan, and another as pasty as you can get. Be sure to use the same exact pose! Here's why: I like both curly and straight, so what attracted me to your straight picture was more your tan, and subconsciously your pose. The angle of your head in the curly pic says to me younger/submissive more than the more confident looking straight shot. Also, in your straight picture your hair is covering your face a bit. It's more sultry and seductive. I like that look more so than an off the face style. All told, the curly picture overall leans girlie and the straight leans hottie. Y'all know hottie is the honey that attracts. Now, that said, again, I'm a wavy hair lover, and there are going to be definite curl fetishists and straight lovers out there. My comment speaks to the other subtle signals you sent. Cheers!
06.26.2009
Jax lebby
I have naturally curly hair, but when I keep it long the weight pulls it out into waves, so I can go either way. My issue is how darn THICK my hair is! I almost always wear it up, curly or not. A male friend of mine recently told me he thinks I should wear it down and curly "like you did in High school". My husband says he doesnt care how I wear it, as long as its long.
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in—maybe get a little famous. And don't worry—you can save a draft!

most liked
Loader_buff
Other topics you might appreciate
Travel Style Career & Money Home & Food Neighborhood & World