Breaking Up with Internet Dating Sites (Part 2)

“I finally acquiesced to the online guy and agreed to meet for a drink after work. I thought, “It’ll be good to get out, have a drink, meet someone new, and have different conversation.”

Oh, for those halcyon days of optimism.

His profile:
Non-smoker: check
Single/divorced/widowed: check
Age range: on the high edge of my range, but check
Lives within 25 miles: check
Religion: he’s open to all: check
Height: he’s open to all: check

Okay, let’s proceed. I’m not into appearance, but, since he called me an ugly freak, let’s discuss his looks. He stated his height as 5'11''. In his photos there’s a clean-shaven, medium-built guy with short, wavy dark brown hair, a nice smile, square shoulders, and a jaw line. Average, regular guy looks.

The man who showed up at the restaurant claiming to be him was at best 5'8'' (that’s being generous), had a week’s worth of beard on his face, long, gray stringy hair, sloping shoulders, the belly the size of an eight months’ pregnant woman, and no discernable chin or neck.

When he said hello, he revealed yellowed teeth. I did not recognize him.

The voice sounded familiar, but I couldn’t place it with the person standing in front of me. After some awkward conversation, it was clear this was the man I met online.

He posted photos that were at least ten years old.

I should have left then. But I wasn’t expecting Mr. Right anyway; I was looking to get out for an hour or two, take a step toward reclaiming my life from the clutches of grief. I stayed to hear him out, find out more about him, see if there was any compatibility. His online dishonesty bothered me. A lot. But since I wasn’t expecting this guy to be The One, I let it slide.

But about those teeth ... I don’t expect toothpaste commercial whites, but the guy before me had badly yellowed teeth. And I mean bad, as in years of smoking resulting in yellow shards protruding from strange colored gums. The only thing more prominently pointing to a health problem were his yellow and bloodshot eyes.

But appearance is not my priority. For the record I have and will willingly date short, fat, bald men. What matters to me is intelligence, respect, sense of humor, kindness, compassion, sincerity, and honesty. I excused the lies of appearance and accepted that he hasn’t accepted that he’s aging. He’s older than me and I knew he would show some signs of aging, but I expected a reasonable likeness to his photos. I was willing to overlook all of that surface stuff and get to know him.

His profile stated that he’s a non-smoker. My profile states that I date non-smokers only. One of us is lying. It’s not me. He reeked of cigarettes. Several long trips he made to the “bathroom” further solidified that he’s a smoker. Especially because he returned smelling more strongly of cigarettes. His smoking habit is enough to eliminate him from all realms of possible future dates. I. Do. Not. Date. Smokers. How much more plainly can I say it? If someone says she doesn’t date smokers, she’s not lying. She means it.

He lost me at the first whiff of stale cigarette smoke. And yes, I should have left then. I regret that I didn’t say, “You smell like you just smoked a carton of cigarettes. I told you I don’t date smokers, so good night and goodbye.”

Instead I thought, “Oh what the heck, I’m here, he seemed nice on the phone, and maybe we can be concert buddies. I’ll have a drink with him.”

I had a drink. I had one glass of wine and a glass of water. In that time, he downed four beers and a shot of tequila.

But it wasn’t just the power drinking and power smoking that bothered me.

7 readers liked this story.
From Around the Web:
03.01.2009
Kerrold
Damn...that sounded bad and gives us 'decent' guys a bad name. Internet dating has it's merits and pitfalls. I think this guy was a jerk and a loser...and most decent guys would have stood up and given him a slap (I don't think he was man enough to punch) when he grabbed you. Unfortunately, many of the bad parties on dating websites are men...luckily you only got out with a bruise...just imagine you had met him at a more discrete location. Don't give up or judge all men by one or 2 bad encounters...you could just push the good ones away too....saying that...take precautions to meetings and sometimes...go with your gut feeling! Hope you find someone worthy. Ciao.
01.07.2009
Trillian
Darien - I think eHarmony is a "better" site for those who are accepted by eHarmony. I was not, and many other people I know were also rejected by eHarmony. If you don't fall into their average numbers they don't let you on their site. However, of the people I know who've successfully met and dated great matches online, most of them were via eHarmony. While that speaks well for eHarmony and the daters they will accept in their fold, the rest of us have to deal with the other dating sites. I hung in there for a long time because I do believe it can work, but after five years, off and on different sites, it's become fatiguing and a waste of money. Stories like yours buoy the weary online daters, make us keep at it, offer hope and optimism. But since eHarmony accepted you, by default you are within "matchable" averages. The odds were in your favor. Especially with the economy squeeze, online dating site memberships aren't worth it for those of us with lower odds and less stamina.
01.06.2009
Darien
I'm very sorry to hear about your bad luck ... that guy sounds like a total nightmare. I met my guy on e-harmony, and still am amazed by it because i completely did not expect to get so lucky and thought i'd have more stories like yours to share. Instead we've been together 1 1/2 years and are going strong. Just remember that dating's all a numbers game. You'll never find the right one if you give up the search, but take time to recuperate if you must!
12.21.2008
TALLGIRL72
I too appreciate all said. I am almost to the point where i think- gosh is there something wrong with ME? I know I am not perfect but i am 36, had 2 kids with my ex hubby i dated from I was 14-28, I have enjoyed a few permiscuois flings but I really want to "date' (hopefully leading to long term) but if not just a good companion and lover and friend. I can take rejection. I am not bad looking for my age but I had two kids and have alot of stress with buying a nice car, and a 4 bedroom house (foolishly aye) myself as well as maintaining a fulltime job of 10 yrs and 2 well behaved kids whom are now 13 and 14. Ex is a good guy just still dont have his s*it together and often is without work =I have to cover it all somehow. The guys I meet my god- I told my friends I cannot affort the cost of dating as well as anymore "telling my life story" trying to get to know someone whom often is unemployed, unatrative and a drug user that in some cases wonder why I am not thin? lol Hugs to all!
12.20.2008
Divinity Lowe
i really appreciate this...... i was there just ten minutes ago... My skin isn't as thick as yours so it only took one.... I guess I haven't found myself yet to know that it's okay to be let go..... eharmony never rejected me but they might as well have.... i could never find anyone...
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in!

Article_sweeps
Most Liked Stories
Loader_buff
Sweeps_offers_article_300_top
Win a $10,000 escape to Jamaica! Enter as often as you wish.
Win a $10,000 escape to Jamaica! Enter as often as you wish.
VIEW ALL