Portion Size, Then Vs. Now


 

Soda  

                                    

Original 8-ounce bottle    12 ounce can                  20-ounce bottle
97 calories                        145 calories                     242 calories

While the 12-ounce can used to be the most common soda option, many stores now carry only the 20-ounce plastic bottle, which contains 2.5 servings of soda. When presented with these larger sizes, humans have a hard time regulating our intake or figuring out what a serving size is supposed to be. A 2004 study, published in Appetite, gave people potato chips packaged in bags that looked the same, but increased in size. As package size increased, so did consumption; subjects ate up to 37 percent more with the bigger bags. Furthermore, when they ate dinner later that day, they did not reduce their food consumption to compensate for increased snack calories—a recipe for weight gain.

Plates

It’s not just food portions that have increased; plate, bowl, and cup sizes have as well. In the early 1990s, the standard size of a dinner plate increased from 10 to 12 inches; cup and bowl sizes also increased. Larger eating containers can influence how much people eat. A study published in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine found that when people were given larger bowls and spoons they served themselves larger portions of ice cream and tended to eat the whole portion.

Prices

32 ounces                                            44 ounces                                 64 ounces
388 calories                                          533 calories                               776 calories
$0.99                                                   $1.09                                        $1.19 

We Americans love to get the most bang for our buck. When confronted with a 32-ounce drink for 99 cents versus a 44-ounce drink for ten cents more, the decision is easy. You’d have to be a sucker not to go big. But our ability to get the most out of our dollar doesn’t always serve us well. Value pricing, which gets us a lot more food or drink for just a little increase in price, makes sense from an economic standpoint, but is sabotage from a health standpoint. A study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association found that Americans consume around 10 percent more calories than they did in the 1970s. Given no change in physical activity, this equates to around 200 extra calories per day, or 20 pounds a year.

What is normal?

Increased portion sizes give us more calories, encourage us to eat more, distort perceptions of appropriate food quantities, and along with sedentary lifestyles, have contributed to our national bulge. Unless you’re trying to gain weight, it might help to reacquaint yourself with serving sizes. The NHLBI tells us that a serving of meat should be the size of a deck of cards while one pancake should be the size of a CD. It’s unlikely that we’ll see a scaling down of food to these sizes anytime soon, so perhaps we should all become familiar with another image: the doggy bag.

50 readers liked this story.
share
POST
Comments
11.20.2009
bradley mayor
the problem with our food is nutrients and genetics. both are a mess, neither will change. corp interests and greed rule our green land
10.30.2009
carbonware
This is a highly misinformed article based on food propaganda. Packaging is far smaller than it used to be for most food items, sure you can order the jumbo sizes but you can also get the .99¢ menu if you choose. 30-40 years ago a large pizza was 25-30 inches, now it's half that I study food and history and these are just false facts that get passed around over and over. What about the 16 Oz. Coke bottle they also sold back in the 50s and 60s? Coffee cups used to be small because people sat and drank a pot of it instead of getting a larger cup to go, People used to put butter and gravy on everything thats changed too. Cereal and ice cream contains have dropped by half over the last 10 years while prices have gone up at 4X inflation. Our problem is exercise, the government planners for years drove us off the land and into the cities and people in cities eat poorly and get little exercise, we work at desks instead of hard labor but we live longer too. Weight gain goes with modern life.
10.26.2009
Gerlad Peters
This is a bunch of nonsense. Slice of pizza according to who? Lender's frozen bagel vs. Gourmet bagel? Twenty years ago you couldn't get a large bucket of popcorn? And the burger comparison is shamefully dishonest.. I don't suppose you are suggesting no one sells small burgers anymore.. Are you? >>. Given no change in physical activity, this equates to around 200 extra calories per day, or 20 pounds a year. By that rationale, why aren't we all 750 lbs? If you really want to lambaste fat Americans for eating more I'm sure you could find some more legitimate evidence, but that would be work, wouldn't it?
10.25.2009
Jon White
Seems deceptive. I remember eating most of the bigger quantities more than thirty years ago. We didn't go by pizza slice size, we simply ate 3/4 to 1 whole pizza. The big tubs of popcorn and Wendies hamburgers were all available in the late 70's and we ate them.
10.18.2009
CD Rates
Pretty interesting analysis of how things have changed. I guess food has become so abundant here that we have increased our portions.
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in—maybe get a little famous. And don't worry—you can save a draft!

most liked
Loader_buff
Other topics you might appreciate