Kindergarten Discipline Woes

By: Laura Roe Stevens (View Profile)

Lately, things have not been going well with my precocious six-year-old son. He went from hating his kindergarten class—to loving it and making new friends—to sowing his rambunctious oats and becoming a class clown. Can any of you relate? Where did my thoughtful little boy go?

So it became apparently clear last week during his class violin performance that he lacks respect for authority. First, he carelessly broke his violin bridge and had to borrow someone else’s violin. (He thought it would get him out of the performance, so I suspect he did it on purpose.) Then he chatted during the entire performance with his best friend. His teacher asked them four times to stop—but he happily carried on. He did this seeing both his parents in the audience who kept giving him “the stern look.” Apparently, that has little effect these days.

When it was his turn to perform, he did so very well—he has no stage fright and of course, picked the easiest piece to do. The next day he got in trouble for chatting during circle time. At a birthday party that afternoon, he kept wrestling and laughing loudly with all the other boys causing the magician to constantly stop and address the trouble makers in the back. Yesterday I learned that William and about five of his friends started a mock sword fight in group string class with their bows and wouldn’t stop when the teacher addressed them. It got so out of control that one child stepped on the bow of another child’s cello and broke it. (Bows cost around £25 pounds, or $50 each.) All the boys missed lunch and were sent to the principal’s office where they had to write down what they did wrong.

I agree with that strategy, as I made William write an apology note to his teacher for chatting during the class performance. But, it isn’t stopping his behavior. Yes, I know he is just six years old and boys will be boys, but when I was his age, I was terrified of getting in trouble. My son laughs it off and sails through his day with the confidence of a cocky teenager.

6 readers liked this story.
share
bookmarks
Comments
posted: 03.12.2008
Aurelle Wells
I loved your story! Reminded me of my youngest son when he was in school. One of his teachers put masking tape on his mouth because he was talking in class! Needless to say,my husband went to school the next day. She didn't pull that little stunt again! So,I totally agree with your disipline measures. I was raised in the South also so I know what you're talking about when you say you were taught to "respect your elders". I have a scar inside my bottom lip now for disrespecting my dad!! Of course that was 42 years ago!We don't do things like that now but restriction and taking away of the things they think they can't do without really hurts at that age. Keep up the good work! You should be so proud and keep in mind, you're going to raise a good, decent young man!
posted: 03.10.2008
Susan Hansted Kuntz
Great article! I agree six year olds need consequences to understand what is expected of them and what will get them the outcome they are looking for. I work with adults and children in creating positive habits for problem solving and conflict resolution. My own son (6.5 yrs.) is a sponge for what I call Possibility Thinking (TM) which gets to the root of behavior instead of what I call "frontal attack". When he runs into trouble at school I ask him to tell me what the situation means to him. Perception is reality for all of us! The problem comes into play when our behavior is driven by a negative interpretation of an event. For instance, my son's friend says "I don't want to play with you today" and my son perceives the situation as final - "he doesn't like me anymore", "he's not my friend anymore" all very sad and hurtful (meanings) interpretations for him. So we play the game of Possibility Thinking(TM). Is it possible that your friend was just in a mood? Is it possible?
posted: 03.09.2008
Cathy Burke
Great piece! I can relate all too well. Your sounds like quite the social butterfly. I do not think the punishment is unfair (six year olds need consequnces) but it might be more effective to alienate him from his audience. I bet he would settle down quicker if isolated for a brief time. Maybe threaten him with doing a solo instead of performing with the whole group if he misbehaves!
posted: 03.08.2008
Shade Elam Maret
I have a son much like yours. I keep a hat on and head down in preschool carpool line. My daughter's completely different. He starts Kindergarten next year so I'm nervous. Suggested reading: ``Raising Cain: Protecting the Emotional Health of Boys'' by Dan Kindlon; and Positive Discipline'' and ``The Spirited Child'' by Mary Sheedy Kurcinka. The latter two were suggested to me by Project Enlightenment here in Raleigh. They've helped me understand him and try to guide him a little better. Thanks for writing that. Nice to know there are others out there!
It feels good to write.

Your stories, musings, and advice are welcome here. We know you've got something to share, so jump in—maybe get a little famous. And don't worry—you can save a draft!

most liked
Loader_buff
Other topics you might appreciate
Relationships Body & Soul Career & Money