Mascara Quest

By: Christine Lennon (View Profile)

I know this seems counter-intuitive, but when it comes to my eyes, I don’t want to risk it with a natural product that hasn’t been through the rigors of big beauty brand testing. As far as I’m concerned, waterproof mascara is the devil’s work. Not only does it make lashes dry hard, spiky and linger, despite repeatedly attempts to remove it, for days after the fact, you can rarely find a formula that looks natural after applying more than one coat.

Even now that I’ve found a mascara that works for me—Maybelline Lash Discovery in Very Black, though this is an entirely subjective choice—I’m still keeping my options and my eyelids open, searching for a consistently irritant-free formula that my eyes can take. My eyes are so sensitive, even the non-waterproof variety has become a special-night only beauty staple, which I promptly erase with a gentle makeup remover as soon as I get home.

And in the meantime, of course, I’m wearing plenty of blush.

 

2 readers liked this story.
share
bookmarks
Comments
posted: 01.20.2008
Lora Leclair
I have HORRIBLE luck with eye makeup. I looked like a commercial for "dry eye" for nearly a week following my senior prom, and all I used was a little liner and some mascara. Since then, I have found that a "moisturizing" mascara put out by Estee Lauder doesn't irritate...if I feel like dealing with the clumps. Thanks so much for the tip! I'll have to keep an eye out for soft or flexible mascara next time I'm out shipping.
posted: 10.04.2007
Gillian S.
My main quest right now is to find a mascara, non waterproof... hate them! that does not smudge! Sephora had an awesome one, but then changed the formula and now i look like a raccoon come 5pm... any ideas? I only want 1 step and have tried, benefit, lancome, dior, cheap stuff from CVS.
posted: 08.27.2007
Veronica Kavanagh
I totally agree about waterproof mascara, it's awful and it makes my eyes itch in seconds. I'm always looking for good mascara. I prefer brown, not brown/black, so I really have troubles. I'm using Dr. Hauschka's brown mascara and I like it. The brush is decent and it doesn't clump $22. I just bought Boots No. 7 black/brown mascara for sensitive eyes at Target and am curious to see how that is. At $8.99, I'm hoping for a find but if not, at least I haven't spent a fortune on something I'll have to throw out. I must be one of the few whose eyes can't bear the Maybelline Great Lash in the pink and green tube. Instant itch and watery eyes.
posted: 08.19.2007
Carin Kimura
I was recently at a Billy B. seminar, and he recommended Voluminous by L'Oreal. Being a makeup artist, I've tried several mascaras and that one, in my opinion, is not the best. If you are willing to spend the money, Imju Fiberwig is amazing. It's $22.00 @ Sephora. It does contain fibers, but they don't fall like the Fiberiche (by MAC) does. If you are looking for something cheaper, Maybelline's Lash Stylist is wonderful since it uses a comb instead of the traditional wand, and there are no fibers. It runs approx. $6.00.
posted: 05.23.2007
Lori Kate
I am a confirmed mascara junkie. I get the best results from using Fresh mascar as a base, then DiorShow to lengthen and create volume and then I seal it with Blinc - it lasts all day, no racoon eyes. I have VERY sensitive skin/eyes, and haven't had any allergic reactions.
Tell us a Story.

You know you've got something to share. Maybe it's something funny, touching, inspirational or informative. Whatever it is, your circle of friends here at DivineCaroline would love to hear from you.

Btn_articletour
most liked
Loader_buff
Other topics you might appreciate
Relationships Play Neighborhood & World Parenting