At one of my final speaking engagements in Australia, I asked the 10th-year girls of St. Aidan’s in Brisbane what was holding them back from taking leadership on issues they cared about. A girl raised her hand but didn’t directly answer the question. She spoke instead of wanting to raise and donate money to important causes. Finally, after my probing about why she didn’t just do it, she said, “What if I fail?”
A collective murmur of agreement became a roar of “YES!” when I asked the 200 girls if that would be true of them as well. I then asked these sports-minded girls if they walked off a field when they missed a goal. Of course, they said no. Failure as part of a team is one thing, I came to realize, but personal failure for these girls is quite another.
I told them about a mentor of mine who said, “People who don’t want to fail shouldn’t get up in the morning.” I talked of the many failures hidden behind each success we achieve. A vice principal chimed in, and we both agreed that we had learned more through our failures than through our successes. The girls, I fear, came away unconvinced. They are high achievers, and they are heavily invested in success.
Interestingly, at the Alliance of Girls’ Schools conference dinner, amid the relics of Australian history at the Melbourne Museum, the guest speaker touched on just this issue, wrought from her own experience in girls’ schools. There was a young Cambodian woman with us, Alice Pung, who had written a book called “Unpolished Gem,” a story of her struggle for success and the role failure played in it. She is now a solicitor (lawyer), and she gave a brilliant and moving speech about her struggles in an immigrant family and with being different in her schools—her isolation and depression, the pressures of family and academics, and finally her breakdown.
This young woman speaks widely now, talking to schools about failure because she understands intimately how it is an unaddressed issue for girls. Sadly, at one school, a principal upbraided her for “encouraging failure” by talking about it. She told the principal that failure needed no help from her.
.gif){kind=icon}
