Closing an Open Relationship: The 4-Way

By: The 4-Way Panel (View Profile)

Dear 4-Way,
My boyfriend and I have had an open relationship for a little over two years. We are free to have safe, physically intimate relationships with other people, but have always said that our emotional relationship would be exclusive. This worked for both of us for a while because we love the fun of the first kiss, the first touch, etc, which you can’t get when you only have one partner.

But my feelings about our relationship have changed. I feel jealous now when he’s with other women. I know that I need to talk to him about it, but I’m afraid—this arrangement is what he wants (and what I used to want) and it’s why our relationship has lasted as long as it has. I don’t want to lose him. Lately I’ve been thinking that since I’ve sucked it up for this long, I can keep doing it if it means keeping him. What do you guys think?—SN, Tacoma, Washington

The straight woman’s perspective: Rebecca Brown
Open relationships intrigue me, because I know I would never be capable of having one. Why, you ask? Because I’m that woman; if you sleep with me, I want your penis all to myself. I’m not a sharer. I’m the only one who gets to admire it, touch it, rub it, ride it, make a puppet for it, or do anything else with it. The end.

But my possessiveness has scientific grounding. When you have an orgasm (and also, interestingly enough, when you have a baby), your body is flooded with oxytocin, a hormone which according to one source “induces feelings of love and altruism, warmth, calm, bonding, tenderness, and togetherness.” Oxytocin has been called “the cuddle hormone.” It helps you bond with someone. (Clearly this isn’t always the case since there are plenty of people who still pull the old love ’em and leave ’em routine.) One study also suggest that higher levels of oxytocin are associated with the reciprocation of trust. And I suspect that this is where the heart of your problem lies.

10 readers liked this story.
share
bookmarks
Comments
posted: 04.18.2008
Nelly Meg
This topic is near and dear to me. I have lived it for more than 30 years. When my husband and I married in 1977, we vowed honesty but not sexual fidelity. Our marriage was to remain the top priority. The arrangement worked fairly well,although better for him, than me and I ultimately asked that we be exclusive. He reluctantly agreed. A few years later he entered into a sexual/emotional relationship without my knowing and that was that. We have been separated for the past 8 years. He left his new relationship after 2 years. I re-entered the dating world with little success. We have decided to try to share a house in the near future because neither of us have found a sustaining relationship and we enjoy each other's company. We are not recommitting to a marriage relationship. Both of us are uncertain about how this will work out ,but nevertheless feel it is worth a try. I am calling it my "grand adventure". I know it will be an adventure but I don't know how grand.
posted: 04.18.2008
Gordon Freeman
I agree with the above comment - it's an unrealistic hollywood-esque expectation to assume that one person can be all things to another - and if they can't, then somehow suffering without having your needs met is in the furtherance of a noble goal. While I understand and respect the tenets and concepts of monogamy, it's silly in this day and age to apply such a narrow-minded viewpoint across virtually all creeds, orientations, and genders. Suffering is NOT noble - but it's an awesome way to build up resentment that can poison the well of any relationship. And given the answers arguing that she should try to get her needs met (up to and including ending the relationship), it's unfortunate that this view doesn't fully encompass the boyfriend's needs and requirements. I call shennanigans!
posted: 04.18.2008
Mike Caprio
There's no arguing that open relationships aren't for everyone. But it's extremely self-righteous to assume that one type of interpersonal relationship is "the right one" no matter how many biological or psychological excuses you try to trot out. You may as well be saying: "Well, experimenting with the same sex is okay for a while, but really, heterosexual sex in the missionary position is the only right way to be having sex and eventually everyone understands that" or even: "Well, the nuclear family of one man and one woman is really the only way to have a stable household. Everyone knows that having multiple step-parents and baby daddies and set-siblings is just a recipe for disaster, and I don't understand why people want to put themselves in that situation." Decrying open relationships is just plain old bigotry and fear.
Tell us a Story.

You know you've got something to share. Maybe it's something funny, touching, inspirational or informative. Whatever it is, your circle of friends here at DivineCaroline would love to hear from you.

most liked
Loader_buff
Other topics you might appreciate
Relationships Body & Soul Style