You are here

Our All-Time Favorite Mascaras

  • AVERY POWELL

    Maybelline New York Mega Plush Mascara, $8

    Who wants extra volume if it means clumpy, stiff lashes? This plumping formula glides on cleanly and stays soft all day long. Sold!

  • L’OREAL

    L'Oreal Paris Voluminous False Fiber Lashes, $8

    "I loved how long my lashes look and that it doesn't smudge."

    - Patricia Duke, LHJ reader

  • CoverGirl LashBlast Clump Crusher Mascara, $7

    Go ahead, pile it on. Thanks to the lab geeks over at CoverGirl, you can apply as many coats as you want (we stopped at four!) and still get clean, pretty lashes.

  • BENEFIT

    Benefit They're Real! Mascara, $23

    "The brush is extra plump and the formula is dry—in a good way. It makes lashes super full, but unlike other lash 'innovations' it's easy to get all your lashes in one swoop."

    - Ann Colville Somma, LHJ reader

  • Mark Platt

    Clinique High Definition Lashes, $16

    Thanks to its brush/comb applicator, you can expect super long and dramatic, yet still clean-looking, lashes. Use the brush to thicken and the comb to separate and style. Lightweight thickeners and soft waxes lengthen without smudging.

  • L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Mascara, $7.50

    "I was turned on to this mascara by Annette Bening years ago and it's still my favorite! Love the formula, the brush, and the intense black color."

    - Brett Freedman, makeup artist

  • Mark Platt

    Chanel Imitable Mascara, $30

    The cone-shaped rubber brush moves easily through lashes, offering the perfect amount of mascara, from root to tip. A volumizing rice wax formula—created to work with this new brush—magnifies lashes, while beeswax keeps them glossy.

  • PETER ARDITO

    Lancôme Définicils Precious Cells, $29.50

    "Just as reliable as classic Définicils, plus it gave me extra volume, length, and curl."

    - LHJ editor

  • PETER ARDITO

    CoverGirl Lash Blast Fusion, $10

    "Loved it! It made my lashes thicker and held the curl, which I so desperately need."

    - LHJ editor

  • PETER ARDITO

    Stila Glamoureyes Mascara, $22

    "Nice thick formula with a rich black color. The wide brush made application easy."

    - LHJ editor

  • BRYAN MCCAY

    Maybelline New York Illegal Length Mascara, $9

    "This mascara is pretty incredible—it goes on smoothly and makes my lashes look so much longer. Best of all, it survived my sweaty boot camp class without smudging."

    - Terri Walsh, LHJ reader

  • PETER ARDITO

    Mally Waterproof Volumizing Mascara, $20

    "Made my lashes really full and held up well, even after yoga and a shower."

    - LHJ editor

Comments

Loading comments...