American Idol -Season 8

Who do you think will win, yet who do you want to win, and lastly who do you actually think would sell more records in the long run... Cook or Archuleta? By the way, when Simon said that next week's finale will be a "humdinger," it's defined as "a striking or extraordinary person or thing." Anyhow, go David COOK, you humdinger you!

I totally agree that Brooke's faces are starting to grate. I really liked her at the start, but if I see her do that "I'm an old man and I have no teeth" weird smile again acting all "it's ok if you don't like me I still love you," I will actually pick up the phone and vote for someone. I have to admit that Jason relaxes me. He's so bloody happy and zen and calm that I should hate him but I don't because I need him in my week. that said I'd never buy an album of his. I want syesha to go first. Ps. just saw in iTunes store––must confess that I was buying the idol gives back song by Daughtry––that Phil Stacey (remember him? bald guy with big eyes and bad hats?) just released an album. No fear of the rest of them if he has an album.

Exactly how many bongs did Paula hit before the show last night? Good lord! Her commentary was confusing, BUT - at least she tried to be a judge last night and offer an actual critique. Even if she WAS judging performances that hadn't even happened yet, God bless her little heart. I only saw the show through bits on YouTube, but Jason Castro, it's time for you to go. You. Suck. For real. And Brooke, you suck too. I'm tired of all your stupid baby faces and sad songs sung at the piano. David Cook, on the other hand, is SIZZLING talented and if he doesn't win, i'm seriously boycotting this show.

I'm still feeling it for Paula. I hope she hit the bottle last night. It's like when you're all dressed up at a wedding and you walk out of the bathroom with the back of your dress tucked into your knickers. That's almost as embarrassing as knocking the second performance before it's even happened. I didn't think it was even possible to lose credibility when you didn't have any--but she did it.

WHY must we endure Jason Castro? That slug has no talent and is on everyone's last nerve. MOVE ON. And Brooke White. Like her, don't love her, but she will last longer than Saiesha. Then we have the two Davids. They will be in the finale fo sho. But you have to ask yourself. Could you really sit through an entire album of David Archuletta's music without slitting some body part? The kid is a bit depressing. Dave Cook would have you rocking the house though. THAT is why he should win. Can we vote Paula off? And make Randy go with her - he's on the nerves. Bring on Neil Diamond this week!!!

And might I add: Ummmm...Paula? What? Huh? Where did all of her words go? They should put a thing in her ear and have someone feed her lines -- this has seriously gotten bad.

OMG: David Cook tonight with the Andrew Lloyd Webber song was crazy unbelievable amazingly wonderfully talented off the charts GREAT! I mean, seriously -- SERIOUSLY -- ahh -- I had some major chills during his performance. Love love love that guy. For some weird reason I still love Brooke White - there's something about her character or her honesty or something. And I love Carly's powerful voice. Don't get me wrong -- David Cook is IT. Yes, the BIG I.T. He is, without a doubt, my A #1. But I still have a little room for the two other girls. Next out: Jason Castro -- Buh -Bye. How did this take so long???

Two words: DAVID COOOOKKKKKK!!! He rocks. He made a Mariah Carey song sound cool, for the love of god - he should win for that alone. I think Paula made her smartest comment of the season after his performance: that really could have been a song in a movie soundtrack. But on a completely separate note - Kristy Lee Cook is gone...finally! I know, she has a pretty voice, but she just isn't at the same level as some of the other people. Next out: Brooke, who also has a pretty voice, but as Simon said to Kristy last night, "I think it's finally time for you to go." Can't wait for ALW performances next week - those should great. Can't say it enough - I loves me some David Cook!

Ding dong the witch is dead. FINALLY KLC is gone. Thank you Jesus and God Bless America! I am glad Simon at long last revealed his true feelings for Carly last night. I have always thought he was so hard on her because he liked her. He has also made many comments about her looks. Last night he said she could be great and that's why he has been riding her like a wild, untamed philly. He loooooves her. So ... who's next? I think Brooke. I am so over Miss Pouty Face; she is a glorified piano lounge singer. I am super stoked about Andrew Lloyd Webber next week. If David Cook sings something from JC Superstar, I will seriously switch teams and get in line for some DC action.

Believe me, I want nothing more than for Kristy Lee to be booted out on her untalented butt, but Michael had to go. Seriously, if he wasn't really really ridiculously good looking, he would have been booted a long time ago. Sure, he did great with Bohemian Rhapsody, but that was ages ago. Since then, he has ripped off Jim Morrison and Aerosmith, and done even more damage to Freddie Mercury, not to mention his horrific mangling of "A Day in the Life." So long MJ. My boy David Cook is still there, so I am happy. But yes, PLEASE America, get rid of KLC. I want Brooke to stay in there as long as possible so she gets ruined by stardom and ends up on Behind the Music after her addiction to pills and booze pushes her over the edge. Sorry, but I was never into the whole innocence thing. I mean, she's married. She can't be that innocent.